Phonics
Most modern language arts curricula say
they make “Phonics” instruction easy. But
we do not want to teach students Phonics!
Phonics does not make the important connection
between spoken and written language. Students
are guided to name and refer to alphabet letters as
alphabet letters. They are not guided to
say a sound and write the printed symbol, or symbols,
that represents the sound. The only way to learn
explicit sound-symbol connections is to explicitly study
sound-symbol relationships! Phonics, which is
thinking with alphabet letters and spelling with
alphabet letters, does not do this.
If the heading on a worksheet is
Study the Short Sound of i, and the
student is instructed to “write i” in
each blank to spell words that contain the short
i sound, he will think, write and see
“alphabet letter i,” but he will not
say and hear “sound
i(it).” In this
activity, “alphabet letter i” does not
compute as “sound
i(it)” except by
inference and students are not drawing this conclusion,
since over two-thirds of our students can’t spell,
write or read at the grade level this worksheet is
introduced. And those who fail to learn to
spell, write and read in this grade do not learn in the
grades
thereafter.